|
Casting is not obsolete but it is
an ancient process that has to compete with more modern manufacturing
techniques. Some of these methods are forging, fabricating (cutting and
welding), stamping, and sintering.
At PicoPascal we want you to think
about having your parts machined from solid blocks of material.
Quicker
Cheaper
Stronger Reproducible
Summary of Casting
over other Manufacture Methods
QUICKER
Casting requires a pattern or mold. If you do not have
a serviceable pattern or mold then repairing or making one is very time
consuming. Most castings require secondary machining. Since castings are
usually irregularly shaped then in addition to the pattern or mold the
machine shop has to make special jigs or fixtures to hold the casting during
machining. The number of steps necessary to make a successful casting is
neither quick nor easy. Presumably your part needs machined; it needs holes
drilled, holes drilled and taped and surfaces flattened. Since the part
needs machined anyway, simply have the whole part machined from a block of
material. A variety of metals, plastics and other machineable materials are
readily available.
CHEAPER
Patterns and molds in addition to being time consuming
are also expensive. Tooling (patterns, molds, & fixtures) costs can run
into thousands of dollars before the first part is cast. If a later change
is made then the tooling costs are repeated. Most production machining is
now performed on modern CNC (computer numerical controlled) machining
centers. Programming the machining of a part cut from a block of material
will take a little longer than just programming the secondary machining of a
casting but consider you have not invested in any tooling. Another big
feature: it is much, much cheaper and quicker to make a design change. It
may only take a minute or two to change a couple lines of code versus a
month or more to change the tooling.
STRONGER
Wrought bar and plate from a mill usually has much
better qualities for strength and toughness than a casting. Castings can be
made strong with special alloys, techniques, and heat treatments but again
this adds time and expense.
REPRODUCIBLE
Castings, especially sand castings, vary from piece to
piece. A foundryman is an artist, a craftsman, and a metallurgist with an
incredible number of variables to deal with. He can make a crude casting
quickly and easily and he can make an extremely sophisticated, accurate, and
strong casting. However, he can not make a sophisticated, accurate and
strong casting quickly, easily or cheaply. When we machine a piece from a
solid block of material we shift the metallurgical issues from the
foundryman to the mill that made the material. A mill that makes much the
same thing every day; a mill that has great control over its processes and
that can guarantee material to difficult specifications. Fixtures for the
machining of castings will often cause distortion and inaccuracies. This is
much less likely when machining from a solid block. Although burrs are
often worse on wrought material the control of burrs is easier. Burrs can
be removed as part of the machining process. On a casting the burrs must be
removed as an additional process such as hand scraping or grinding.
SUMMARY
You have a number of variables to consider. Deadlines,
quantity, quality, and flexibility all have to be compared. At one extreme
is the aerospace industry; they may make a block of material into 98% chips
for the recycle bin and 2% into a useable part. Previously, they would have
riveted many pieces of sheet metal together to make the same part. In this
case a casting was not an option due to lack of consistency and strength.
In the case of an existing part, if you use about a thousand pounds (500 Kg)
or more of castings per year and quality is acceptable then casting is
probably the way to go. Large and very small parts are best left as
castings. The intermediate sized part is most favorable for change. Very
favorable parts are the size of your fist or the shape of a book. A
questionable part might be shaped like a picture frame. Every part will
have to be evaluated individually to see if machining from a block makes
sense. Due to ever increasing labor and environmental costs and improved
productivity of modern CNC machinery the breakeven point between machining
from a block and casting is shifting to machining from a block. A high
speed, 5 axis machining center such as the one owned by PicoPascal Company
allows one to machine features quickly that in the past were only
realistically made by casting.
|